Lakefront real estate
White Lake, NY

White Lake (motorboat lake)

White Lake is a 280 acre motorboat lake about 8 miles west of Monticello. It’s one of the most popular (and busiest) lakes here, and one of the few that features both commercial and residential development, with a number of lakeside restaurants as well as boat rentals and dock space. There is public access, including a DEC boat launch. White Lake is also convenient to the Bethel Woods Center for the Arts, about 4 miles west.

White Lake isn’t a single lake community with an overarching homeowners association, but rather a collection of varied communities that ring the lake. Along the northern shore of the lake is White Lake Homes, a community of modest lakefront and non-lakefront homes largely built in the 1960’s. White Lake Homes has an outdoor pool, tennis courts, a community beach and dock space available for non-lakefront homeowners

The eastern side of the lake has a range of residential options, including a small townhouse community, a lakefront coop, a small condominium, and free standing houses, ranging from modest cottages to larger, more opulent houses.

White Lake’s southern shoreline runs along Route 17B, and is largely commercial, but with a handful of lakeside houses. Along the southwest side of the lake is the Beechwoods Club section, mostly modest lake cottages with a row a larger houses along the northern end, and then a small community of houses along Naylor Road.

Lake houses on White Lake are fairly tightly packed, with most on 1/4 an acre or less. Higher density is permitted along most of White Lake because most of the area is served by a community sewer system, rather than on-site septics. Smaller lakefront cottages with about 50′ of frontage start here about $250,000, and larger lakefront houses can range up to the $600,000 range. The handful of very large houses here, or houses on an acre or more of land, might fetch in the million $ range if one was on the market. Non-lakefront cottages or houses start at around $125,000, but can vary widely depending on dock space, lake access and setting.

While some parts of White Lake are quieter and more ‘secluded’ than others, this is not a top lake choice for buyers looking for that quiet “On Golden Pond” lake retreat. This is a great lake, though, for buyers who want a lake with activity, and can hop in their boat to grab dinner at a restaurant across the lake, enjoy visiting with neighbors from the end of their dock, and like watching water skiers, jet skiers and wave boarders playing on the lake.

White Lake Quick Facts
  • Motorboat lake
  • Public access
  • 98 miles from the George Washington Bridge
  • Approx. 280 acres
  • Restaurants, boat rentals and dock space on the lake
  • Parcel sizes: < 1/4 acre to an acre
  • House prices: Lakefront: $250,000 to $1M. Non-lakefront: $125,000 to $250,000.

White Lake Resources:


Benji and Jakes (pizza & craft beer)

The Local Table & Tap

The Fat Lady Cafe (Facebook page)

Bubba’s Barbeque

Java Love Coffee Roasters


Bradstan Country Hotel

Boat Rental

Payne’s Watersports

Lake information

DEC White Lake page